2/6/08

Positive New Music Criticism!

Hey! Some people do like new music! This is a pleasant review of what sounds like a good concert. The opening sentence draws you in…

Salonen and company triumph in a far-reaching MusicNOW program

A funny thing can happen if you take a classical newbie to a MusicNOW concert.

I like where this is going. What is that funny thing?

Now in its 10th year, the new music series challenges most preconceptions by having (living!)

Good heavens!

composers present their works to an audience and then even mingle with listeners afterward. A sense of worship is replaced with the spirit of camaraderie.

That sounds outstanding. This mingling element is a fantastic part of the new breed of contemporary concerts. I recommend this. Is that the funny thing? Camaraderie? Because…you brought a newbie? No, that’s not it.

Add in the sleek contemporary space of the Harris Theater for Music and Dance, and classical music gets a complete image makeover.

This “complete image makeover” is slightly exaggerated, but I approve of the sentiment.

So, what’s the funny thing that can happen when you take a “classical newbie” to such an event? Is it the image makeover? Because that doesn’t seem predicated on whether you bring someone or not.

On Monday night, there was much to gain from witnessing first-hand newer works by composers Esa-Pekka Salonen, Oliver Knussen and Rolf Wallin. CSO Mead composer-in-residence Mark-Anthony Turnage hosted a far-reaching program that included fragments of a David Lynch-like horror (by Wallin) and a contemporary take on Stravinsky's "A Soldier's Tale" (by Salonen).

That sounds interesting! I would like to see this concert.

Wallin's "LautLeben" (1999) was conceptually the evening's most unique creation. This daring electronic multimedia work comes from the school of Stockhausen, but takes enough risks to make its headmaster seem like Shirley Temple.

More risks than putting a string quartet in four helicopters?

Jazz soprano Sidsel Endresen, like Wallin a Norwegian (and who collaborated with him on the work), soloed in a way that Wallin described as if "her voice was traveling inside herself." Technology contorted her vocals around electronic tapes playing spastic throat calls and vertiginous squeals. An enormous screen behind the soprano projected glowing images that radiated delicately in the pitch-black theater.

I know it’s hyperbole, but that sounds like a lot of multimedia works. Which is fine, but not particularly “daring”. Small point.

So spacey was the work that Endresen had to inform the audience it was over, but she captivated nonetheless.

Sounds like she was very good. You might want to avoid the passive voice, though. However: I’m still waiting for the funny thing that can happen!

Back on earth, Knussen's short chamber symphony, "Songs Without Voices" (1992), scored for eight instrumentalists, revealed a more conventional work. Amy Dissanayake's liquid pianism and near perfect touch went a long way with CSO cellist Jonathan Pegis' effortless vibrato. Thorny harmonies crept in and out, but this was a seductive romance at its core.

Thorny harmonies might scare the “newbie”! That’s not the funny thing, is it? Because I think it's kind of funny.

Salonen, the veteran music director of the Los Angeles Philharmonic, had just come off a busy weekend guest-conducting the Chicago Symphony Orchestra in Mozart's Mass and Knussen's Violin Concerto. When he moves on from the L.A. Philharmonic in 2009, he plans to devote more time to composing.

Salonen's "Catch and Release" (2006) is a rapidly changing, small-scale gem which provided poignant solos from CSO violinist Nancy Park and trombonist Charles Vernon. The maturity apparent in the last movement's brisk and bracing rhythms attested to a composer first, conductor second.

That sounds cool, too! I like his conducting but only know a little of his music. Now, you’re done describing all of the works. You can totally concentrate on telling me about that funny thing…the thing? That you described in your first sentence?

The article’s over?

(sigh)

The Interview

This one requires a little imagination.

Paint a picture in your mind of a job interview. Sitting on opposite sides of an uncomfortably large desk, the interviewer asks the interviewee some questions.

“So, Mr. ... “

“It’s Scott, sir. St... Stephen Scott.”

“Thanks. Stephen, it says here you are from Colorado Springs?”

“That’s right. That’s... that’s right. For... for... for... almost forty years, now.”

“It also says, here, that you were a minimalist.”

“Ye... ye... yes, sir. I tend... I tend... to repeat myself a lot. But... but... but... I create sweet... m... melodies.”

“And what is your specialty, Mr. Scott?”

“I’m good at creating the effect of d... dappled light on waves.”


-long silence-


"Can you also create the effect of paddling canoes?"

[Edit: the remainder of the text and the links have been lost. Sorry]
-

Composer of the Day!

Today’s Composer of the Day is Kamran Ince.

(b. 1960)

Born in Montana, he moved to Turkey when he was six. He has won the Prix de Rome, among other notable awards.

He teaches at the University of Memphis. He also co-founded the Center for Advanced Research in Music at Istanbul Technical University.

His music is really cool. It’s been described as post-minimalist. Although, I think the label does his music an injustice. The music rhythmically rocks-out, sometimes. It stays put, just kind of undulating, sometimes. It’s sort of tonal, but non-functional, sometimes. It’s a little avant-garde, sometimes. And a little jazzy, sort of, sometimes. But it’s always well done and tight.

His picture is really fun to look at, but I don't know if he's a Socialist.

You should listen to his music.

2/5/08

Regarding An Exciting Major Musicological Discovery!

I’ve been searching around the websites of various major newspapers to see if anyone, anyone at all, has “classical” music under the “music” tab. Invariably, so far, no. The classical reviews and articles are under “arts”. So either “classical” music isn’t music, or “pop” music isn’t art?

But that’s not why I’m typing right now. I am typing because I think I can make a lot of money by offering my services as an editor to writers who write about “classical” music. Because, apparently, that occupation has been eliminated.

The old times return to symphony

The Houston Symphony's latest classical program triggered memories of old times at the performance Saturday in Jones Hall.

That sounds delightful, if slightly reactionary. Let’s get in our Packards and go see it!

The guest conductor was Lawrence Foster, music director of the orchestra in the 1970s,

Okay. A visit from an old friend. Aw, sentimental. That is sweet.

and he brought a program that once was typical bread-and-butter of orchestral programming:

That’s fine; not every orchestra concert has to champion new music. I guess. What were they playing, I wonder?

George Enescu's Romanian Rhapsody No. 2,

Ah! Nice. This piece sort of fell out of favor, but it used to be a staple. A warhorse-y staple. Or a staple-y warhorse. A chestnut. You know: standard orchestral repertoire. It’s a showy violin feature that incorporates (as the title suggests) some elements of Romanian folk music.

Wolfgang Mozart's Piano Concerto No. 25

Oh, Wolfgang Mozart. Just kidding. That’s a good piece, I think; is it the C Major, K.503? I think so. Yes, it is.

and Johannes Brahms' Symphony No. 5.

Well, I certainly…what? WHAT?!?!

OH MY GOD.

(breathless.) Oh my fuckin’ god.

Fuck! The...

Ohgod ohgod ohgod.

They found a fucking Fifth Symphony by Brahms? Holy tittyfucking christ. Shiva H. Vishnu. That is insane. Insane! How did I not hear about this shit?! Grrblahh! Fruznelesnsz! [head explodes]

I have to get some water. Or a drink. I…I have to…call the NY Times! How did I miss this? Oh sweet mary jane in a pretty glass pipe. I almost had an accident in my…wait, what?

...Similarly, though Brahms was nearing the "little blue pill" stage of his life when he wrote the Fourth Symphony…

What.

You did not. You. Did. Not just do that.

It was a fucking typo?

A typo. Jesus. I about had a seizure there.

You have to be fucking kidding. You did not catch that?

Nobody…caught that?

(exhales loudly)

Insanity. Proofreading is dead. Which is disturbing. I mean...?

Also:

Similarly, though Brahms was nearing the "little blue pill" stage of his life when he wrote the Fourth Symphony…

Are…are you implying that…that Brahms was, or should have been on Viagra?

Fuck you to hell. I am not even going to deal with the rest of your article.

Me, Dances With Scherzo

It’s somewhat disturbing how critical reviews lack the relevant research, or references, often required to speak authoritatively about particular works. The results tend to be meaningless, gerund-ridden, adjective-laden fluff. Immediately, this comes to mind.

I was delighted, however, to come across this review by Tom Strini, who actually used a little analysis, albeit someone else’s, to shed some light on the mysteries of Beethoven’s First Symphony. The only problem here is that he attempts to translate the analysis for the average reader, which becomes intolerably insulting.

Musicologist Elaine Sisman [...] argues that Beethoven advanced a particular agenda in this symphony: He [sic] wanted to climb aboard the same pedestal as Haydn and Mozart. Beethoven did not choose the key of C major by accident. C was the key of the fanfare, of the declarative and robust. The “Jupiter” Symphony, Mozart’s 41st, final and most famous, is in C. So is Haydn’s Symphony No. 97, one of his best-known [sic] then and now.

Sisman believes Beethoven modeled his symphony on those two works. She cites the similar Mozart/Beethoven harmonic plans in their first-movement development sections, and she notes that both placed peculiar digressions into miasmic, tonally unstable minor mode [sic] between the second theme and the closing theme.


I have a couple of problems with Sisman’s assertions, but nothing major. Now, for us music illiterates, take it away Strini!

That sounds a little technical, but if you hear the piece this weekend, the creepiness of these passages will explain just what Sisman means.

One, the Milwaukee Symphony only played the Beethoven, not the Mozart. So I think it would have been extremely difficult to listen to both of the passages at the concert. Two, Sisman’s analysis wasn’t all that technical, if you ask me; all you needed to get was that there are structural similarities, particularly harmonic similarities, between the two opening movements’ middle sections. Three, how on this good, green Earth, if you actually had been able to compare the development sections, could a sense of “creepiness” confirm Sisman’s thesis? I mean, there’s Tom Cruise creepy; and then there’s Mel Gibson creepy.

She believes that both Mozart and Beethoven alluded to genre music from “ombra,” opera scenes among ghosts or in the underworld.

That could be creepy, I’ll admit. But I don’t understand how similar harmonic plans translate to creepiness. Could you please elaborate for me?

The ombra effect in the First Symphony is arresting, and foretells even spookier things to come in later symphonies.

It’s... eye-catching? That’s why it’s creepy? That’s how they’re similar? Beethoven gets creepier?

So much for that. Maybe Papa Haydn can teach us something.

One of Beethoven’s most striking effects in the First Symphony comes at the very beginning. He starts with a C7 chord; the B-flat within it is alien to C major and points to the key of F.

I’ll buy that. But, does this have something to do with how Beethoven tried to attain Mozartean or Haydnian status?

Beethoven feints tentatively toward this key and that, through 12 long, slow bars of introduction. He gives us a C chord in measure 8, but it doesn’t really feel like home.


So no. Thanks for the info. (sigh) Go on, then.

Finally, at the end of measure 12,

I’m starting to dislike how Strini never spells-out a number. My problem, I guess. Go on.

... the strings tumble into a root-position C, firmly establish the home key, tear off at a break-neck tempo and change the mood decisively.

I once wet my pants during first-grade square dancing. Naturally, I wanted to hide it; so, I remained seated on the floor. But that wicked, wicked teacher made me get up and dance. Boy was that embarrassing. My jeans were several shades darker than they once were. The girl with whom I was partnered squealed with disgust. Oh boy, here it comes; I thought to myself, “Jesus shit-Christ.” Of course, she pointed and laughed. By the time the whole class was rolling on the floor laughing at me, the teacher had grabbed me by the arm and whisked me away to the bathroom to clean up. I, too, can change the mood decisively.

Go on.

The moment is astonishing,

(unenthusiastically) Why?

... all the more so, because that C in measure 13 both supplies the relief of long-delayed resolution and launches an entirely new impulse.

I’m beginning to think that the whole I-researched-some-stuff-and-want-share-it-with-you thing is the wrong approach. Besides, whatever happened to his girlfriend, Sisman? What happened to Beethoven striving for things? Or copying people?

... Strini? Hello?

The harmony is Beethoven’s technical means for creating the kind of Eureka moment that anyone, musically literate or not, can understand.

Just a retranslation here: anyone can understand Beethoven’s “I Found It!” moments, because of the harmony. Okay. So what about the harmony? Is it the same harmony that he stole from Mozart’s developments? Or was it referring to the harmony in just the first thirteen measures?
I’m confused. I don’t understand why Strini said that. By correlate, would Mozart’s harmonies also create “Eureka?” moments anyone could... I don’t know.

I better let Strini explain this one.

In subsequent works...

We’re not talking about subsequent works! Are we? I thought this was about the First Symphony, or Tom Cruise vs. Mel Gibson creepiness.

... Beethoven often elaborated on the notion of feeling toward a tonality, as if for a handhold on a fog-shrouded cliff.

Whoa! Hold up a minute. The notion of feeling-toward-a-tonality? Or the notion of feeling, toward a tonality? ...!?!?!?... Beethoven is on a cliff? He’s scaling a cliff? How can he elaborate on scaling a cliff? Is it a tall cliff?

It’s almost characteristic of his style,

So it only seems like he’s scaling a cliff.

culminating in the opening of the Ninth Symphony.

But he is scaling a cliff, with his feelings, toward a notion of tonality, which is almost what he does, and then did. (cries alone in a corner, which is like a cliff, of feeling, shrouded in fog)

But Beethoven did not invent it.

(wipes tears from face, goes back to Journal Sentinel Arts page)

The scaling a cliff part, (sniffle) or the “I found it!” part?

Sisman points out that Haydn opened his Symphony No. 97...

Also known as the “Fat Friend Who Makes You Look Better” Symphony.

...with a slow, off-tonic, introduction.

So Beethoven lifted more material. First he stole Mozart’s development, and creepiness; now, he’s stealing introductions from Papa Haydn. What a hack!

Haydn reused the chord progression of the introduction later in the first movement, and Beethoven followed suit.

What an unoriginal, glass-eyed hack! I hope he didn’t also steal sonata form, or minuet form, or scherzo form, or rondo... What’s that? He did? Jerk.

Did Beethoven consciously model his First Symphony on Mozart and Haydn?

Ah, finally, the point emerges.

Sisman thinks he took his cues from the “Jupiter” and the 97th to honor Mozart and Haydn, to announce his place in their tradition...

Beethoven on a rooftop, naked: “You hear that, world! I am asserting myself in a tradition! Take that!”

... and to exercise some one-upmanship.

That must’ve been why he “borrowed” heavily from those cherry-picked symphonies. How does he exercise it? The one-upmanship?

The one-upmanship lies in part...


Listen carefully, composers. You may, one day, want to assert yourself in a tradition and get your one-upmanship. This is exactly how to do it.

... in Beethoven’s tremendous forward drive,


You hear that? Forward drive.

... with a daring, banging tympani part, springy dotted rhythms and on-the-fly antiphonal exchanges between winds and strings.

Got all that? Good. What else?

Beethoven labels his third movement with the traditional “Minuet,” but it is nonetheless a wild, rollicking scherzo.

You were right, he did steal the scherzo. That bum.

He really challenges the wind players; the First Symphony is almost as much band music as orchestra music.

Beethoven really showed Mozart and Haydn good.

Some early critics complained about its explosiveness.

Or did he?

Still, he was extending a tradition, not blowing it up.

So, extending a tradition equals one-upmanship. Air-tight logic, there. I won’t touch it.

Beethoven demonstrates an absolute grasp of the techniques and strategies of his forbears [sic], in his key plans, in his classical structural proportions, in melodic materials that are contrasting but compatible, and in his uncanny economy of means.

You, Forbears. Me, Dances with Scherzo. [Sorry. I have no real complaint. I just don't like that word.]

I know it’s been a while, but I don’t remember discussing classical structural proportions. Nor do I remember talking about contrasting melodic materials and their compatibility. Oh, yeah. I also don’t remember anything about Beethoven’s uncanny economy of means.

This is getting silly. Seriously, this is what the article sounds like:

Beethoven is interesting. He wanted to be really good. Sisman says that he may have borrowed things from Mozart and Haydn to do that. She also says that he borrowed a creepy thing from opera. The first few measures are pretty cool. Later, he scaled cliffs in the fog. Hadyn did cool things, first. But Beethoven really, really wanted to be good. So he made his pieces with forward drive. He also used other techniques that he learned from his Four Bears, but I don’t want to talk about them.

Am I really all that far-off?

Beethoven was willful, and this music sounds willful.

...?...

But very little in the First Symphony is arbitrary, even when Beethoven recomposes a recapitulation or sees to a bit of developmental unfinished business by enlarging a coda.

On the other hand, I dislike ice cream on cold days. I remember once I had some ice cream on a cold day and the record store was closed. And Mom wouldn’t allow us to come inside until Dad mowed the lawn. But the Civil War escalated beyond the point of zero French involvement.

We didn’t talk about any of this. Ever. Ever. ...!??!?!...

(goes back to corner, curls up, eyes redden)

The First Symphony, historically, has been discounted as Haydnesque...

I prefer Haydnian.

... and, therefore, backward-looking.

(cries)

True, Beethoven went further in later works; the First does not point toward Romanticism to the degree of the Sixth or the Ninth.

(yells from across room, tears flowing)

But we were talking about the First Symphony! Jerk!

But the First is no mere promising work by a young fellow finding his voice. Beethoven knew exactly what he was about, down to the smallest detail.

( yells from across room)

Yeah! He was about stealing things from Mozart and Haydn just so he could throw it back in their faces! I hate reading these things!

He was after brilliance in the First Symphony, and he got it.

(screams from across room)

But this wasn’t about brilliance!

(gets up, finds Dad’s gun, inserts muzzle of gun into mouth, ...)
-

A Texasman in New York

I liked this review pretty well. The writer wrote well. However, the anti-modernist bias continues to drip bile that leaves nasty stains on even the best-intentioned accounts of early modern music.

MET Chamber Ensemble engagingly offbeat

NEW YORK – Arnold Schoenberg, Anton Webern and Alban Berg were among the seminal figures of 20th-century music.

True!

But nearly a century after their first essays in composing with all 12 tones of the octave, as opposed to the eight notes of traditional major and minor keys,

But…Bach used all 12 notes of the octave. Constantly. Regularly. So did Chopin. And Mozart. And basically every post-Renaissance composer, ever. Even some Renaissance composers did.

these three and their followers remain hard sells.

Sort of. As I’ve discussed before, perhaps often, the narrative of “nobody likes this music” is not helpful in this regard. Perhaps the reviewer doesn’t like this music?

In your wildest dreams, can you imagine the Dallas Symphony Orchestra playing a piece by Webern?

Yes. Yes, I can. It’s not really that wild a dream, either. It should be noted here that the reviewer writes for the Dallas Morning News and is in New York. Those crazy liberal East Coasters and their hundred year-old unlistenable music!

Even the Dallas-Fort Worth modern-music series avoid this whole chunk of repertory as if it were radioactive.

This is an argument? We’re not talking about really obscure pieces here, either. Pierrot Lunaire is, perhaps, Schoenberg’s most popular and accessible work. I found dozens of available recordings without even trying.

But James Levine, music director of the Metropolitan Opera and Boston Symphony Orchestra, has been a long-standing champion of Schoenberg and company.

True! Good research.

On Sunday evening, at Zankel Hall, the chamber-music hall buried in the bowels

Nice choice. The “bowels” are, I reckon, where the “shitty” music lives.

of Carnegie Hall, he and the MET Chamber Ensemble served up two-and-a-half hours' worth.

Of shit?

In retrospect, the revolution led by Schoenberg was inevitable.

I guess, in retrospect, it could be seen that way. Schoenberg certainly thought so. This is the “inevitable stylistic progress” narrative, and is invoked frequently enough. It is problematic, though. That’s probably for another time. We have more prose…

To the big narrative forms of late romanticism, it responded

It = the revolution? The revolution responded? Cool! That must have been something.

with stark disruptions and miniatures of wispy gesture and clattery cataclysm.

This is slightly unclear. How many things are there in this sentence? Three? “Stark disruptions,” “miniatures of wispy gesture,” and “clattery cataclysm”? Or is it “stark disruptions” and “miniatures of wispy gesture and clattery cataclysm”? Disruptions and miniatures are not…the same kind of thing, and it’s funny to phrase it this way. I think what he means is possibly “miniatures that feature stark disruptions, wispy gestures, and clattery cataclysm”?

Anyway, bonus points for “clattery cataclysm”. I just want to say that over and over. Try it!

Supersaturated harmonies based on predictable tensions and releases gave way to arbitrary unpredictability.

Honestly, I don’t know what this means. The music is…predictable, yet unpredictable. Or: the big, narrative late Romantic forms' predictability was replaced with unpredictability? That sounds like a positive thing. Right? No? We like our art to be predictable? Sigh.

Composed between 1909 and 1934, Sunday's fare covered quite a range of scale. There were the miniatures of Webern's Four Pieces for violin and piano (Op. 7),

Awesome pieces. Totally tiny and quiet, with subtle tone color manipulations. A little dense and hard to get at first. But cool.

Berg's Four Pieces for clarinet and piano (Op. 8)

Also awesome. More post-romantic and full of notes. Pretty accessibly expressionistic.

and Schoenberg's Six Little Piano Pieces (Op. 19)

Transcendent pieces. Great for beginning study of atonal style, and also analysis. I recommend this. Analysis. Of these pieces. And, well, in general. And these pieces in general.

At the maximalist end lay Berg's massive Chamber Concerto for piano and violin with 13 wind instruments. Atonal or not, this music can sometimes seem a jumble of tonal fragments.

That is true, especially of Berg. He retained various tonal elements in some of his works.

The Berg Chamber Concerto sometimes sounds like busy neoclassical counterpoint patched in and out of sync.

Sort of. Okay. But it’s cool right? Or good? What? Bad? Bueller?

The Schoenberg piano pieces seem like peeks into miniature worlds of sometimes haunting beauty.

Yeah. Rad.

What could have been a mortification of the flesh came across as genuinely engaging, at times downright seductive, thanks to performances lovingly detailed and finely finished. Standouts among the performers were Mr. Levine (a deft pianist as well as conductor), violinists Gil Shaham and David Chan, pianist Yefim Bronfman and clarinetist Anthony McGill.

You…you liked it? Or some of it? Awesome. That is great. Or did you just like the performances of the awful music? Or the performers? I’d like to hear more about what you think, sir.

And veteran soprano Anja Silja made a riveting experience of Schoenberg's Pierre lunaire, its speech-song settings of Otto Erich Hartleben poems as disturbing as the rawest expressionist paintings.

Good. That sounds good. Like I said, that piece is famously liked by people who don’t really like this music. So: what was good? I also want to hear some more about the chamber music you mentioned in the previous paragraph.

…

That’s it? Oh. Okay. That's kind of disappointing. It almost seems as though you didn't hate it because famous people were performing in New York.

Next time, I'd like to hear some more, please.

Our Immortal Beloved

I feel particularly bad, today. On a day when there are all kinds of post-worthy articles to rip, I felt drawn to this guy, again. Not simply because he hates new things—and he hates new things in this, as well. But he has this intangible knack for putting his foot in his mouth on a regular basis. The majority of his comments are often tainted with backhanded compliments and, I’m not sure what to call it so I’ll call it: elder-generation-isms.

Women in high office are becoming such a nonissue that listeners could visit Xian Zhang conducting the Orchestra of St. Luke’s on Sunday afternoon and just listen.

While this almost sounds like a good thing, i.e., women no longer seem out of place in leadership roles, our beloved author makes it sound like he’s just discovered equality. He’s like, “you don’t have to ogle her like a freak show; you, the audience--and take it from me--should just accept this and listen to the music.” Why does he need to state this? What possible reason does he have to draw attention to such an antiquated non-debate?

Being female and Chinese in the classical music business are helpful in getting yourself noticed...

But he just said that women in “high office” are a nonissue. Why, then, would anyone pay particular attention to the fact that she is a woman? Unless, he’s saying that being a Chinese woman is an issue—one that gets you noticed, like women in the workplace did for our author back when Eisenhower was in office. The tone is strangely derisive. Either that or our author has a fever.

... but careers are built [...] on substance.

I think can I agree with that—that being female and Chinese doesn’t ensure success. I just hope, for her sake, Xian Zhang has substance.

Ms. Zhang has it.

Oh good. That was painful. All he said, or needed to say was this: Ms. Zhang has substance. Instead, our Mr. beloved gives us this weird spiel about women, and especially Chinese women, because Xian Zhang is a Chinese woman.

That’s how our immortal beloved begins his article. He also says something weird about German tourists.

2/4/08

Composer of the Day!

Today's Composer of the Day is Conlon Nancarrow.

(1912-1997)

Nancarrow was an experimental composer. He trained with well-known composers Walter Piston and Roger Sessions, among others. After returning from the Spanish Civil War, he went to New York and was involved in the vibrant new music scene there.

He wrote difficult rhythmic music in an atonal, contrapuntal style.

In fact, his music was so rhythmically thorny that he became frustrated with performers' inability to play his complex textures.

Also, he was a dedicated socialist. In America in the 1930s, this was not so cool with the establishment. As a result, he moved to Mexico, becoming a citizen in 1955.

In Mexico, there were even fewer musicians to play his already hard-to-perform music. So he bought a player piano! Which is badass. He wrote many, if not most, of his later works for the player piano, punching holes in the piano rolls, which alleviated the problem of his complex rhythms.

His music is very cool. He was born in Arkansas. There is a relatively recent book about him.

You should listen to his music.

Mr. Holland's Wooden Shoes

Get yourself a drink, or two, and settle in.

We’ve all been privy to those awkward moments when our elders regale about the old days of yore. Like when your grandfather, in a gruff voice, said something like, “I remember the day when people had to sharpen pencils in order to write things. You even had to write it by hand. Not like these new-fangled interwebs and their automatic typers. Then you’d have to lick a sticky paper stamp and fix it to an envelope, which was like taping a coin to the outside. I remember coins, you could buy a whole three-course meal, with a cherry pie at the end, with just one halfpenny, which took a week to earn on my paper route. Where was I? Pies. I remember pies, especially Mrs. Wilson’s pie. Her pie was delicious. Then you’d have to take that envelope to the local negro and have him go to the United States Post Office and send it off. Four months later, you might get a reply.”

Similarly awkward, Mr. Holland is still trying to tell us about the virtue of his wooden shoes, as opposed to those unfamiliar, difficult, soulless, unpopular new Converse High-tops. Or, if you prefer, substitute “wooden shoes” with “stuff he likes,” and substitute “Converse High-tops” with “Elliott Cater.”

Prototypically American, Atypically Challenging

I bet Mr. Holland doesn’t like America.

Mr. Carter, approaching his 100th birthday and subject of the Focus! 2008 weeklong series of concerts at the Julliard School, could not be mistaken for a soulful Russian, a singing Italian or a Central European bearing the weight of the centuries.

So Americans are not soulful, like Russians; they aren’t songbirds, like Italians; they aren’t Jesuses, like Central Europeans. And neither is Elliott Carter. But what could his music be mistaken to be?

In his music there is no patina [the green film of oxidation on bronze after many years], only fresh paint.

Okay... his music is not old; it’s new. Yep. That’s exactly what his music could be mistaken to be, new! Well, not quite the answer I was looking for. I mean Russians are soulful! What are Americans? New!??

And what about Holland’s metaphor, paint? I don’t know if he really thought this one through, because paint, as I understand it, is something attached to a surface. Is Holland saying that Carter’s music lack depth? Or is it just new? Keep that one in mind as we go along. It might resurface.

The edges are not worn smooth but sharp to the touch.

Okay, it’s new. I got it. Everyone else got it. (keep in mind: “new,” and “sharp”)

James Levine conducted the Julliard Orchestra in the “Symphonia: sum fluxae pretieum spei” and the Cello Concerto, a very large mouthful of Mr. Carter’s art and one that assuredly left these splendid musicians and a packed Saturday night house...both satisfied and exhausted.

Keep in mind: “very large mouthful.” I omit “satisfied” and “exhausted,” for now, because this is not Holland’s opinion. I don’t think he has ever been satisfied with new music.

The cellist Dane Johansen was brave and virtuosic and needed to be both.

This, however, is Mr. Holland’s opinion. He thinks that the cellist needed to be brave. Why? To do what he has been training for his entire life, to play the cello? Or was Elliott’s music just that intimidating and the cellist had to be brave in order to face it, like an American Gladiator? I think that Holland thinks that Elliott Carter is a monster. What do you think?

The idea of Mr. Carter as American-made makes sense.

Oh yeah. How?

There are the reserves of psychic energy: the impulsiveness and aggression, the hard work achieved through high sophistication, the absence of neurosis.

Mr. Wooden Shoes calls Carter: impulsive, aggressive, highly sophisticated, and cold, cool and unexpressive. Gee-willickers, Wally. Is Holland saying that Americans are these things, too?

Please note, though, his use of “highly sophisticated.” It has been my experience that Holland uses this term ad libitum, for anything new that he doesn’t understand, or like (it’s placation—it sounds nicer). I’m sure, if he ever looked at, or heard, “Row, Row, Row Your Boat,” with any understanding of music whatsoever, that he’d find it a very sophisticated tune. It might not be as sophisticated as his Puccini, but it’s certainly complex and worthy of the moniker: “highly sophisticated.”

It’s one of the most egregious and backhanded compliments hands down. And remember, this is what he’s also saying about Americans, too.

The concerto greets us with the musical equivalent of gunshots.

Gunshots greet me with a sensation of fright and pain (my ears hurt). Thus, in Holland’s veiled words, Carter greets us with pants-wetting, ear pain. Nice. Carter is an American.

The contrasting lyrical writing sings gracefully; it shines but without a hint of sweetness.

And although Americans sing gracefully, they are not sweet, like Italians, who sing.

The “Symphonia” gathers three movements composed separately that together constitute an evening of listening all in themselves. Mr. Carter makes no pretense of simplicity. He has that American knack for making complex constructions work.


Americans work hard and Carter’s complex constructions work. But damn, it’s dense. That reminds me of a story my grandpa once told me about the war.

“Those damn mortar shells got my buddy, Danny. He had a girl back in Chattanooga, who always made him cookies. He’d go over to her place and put the bunny in the hole. Then she’d make him some cookies. Chocolate Chip, I think. Anyways, when we made it to Burgandy, I found a little doll on the side of a bombed-out road. It was covered in mud. Which was the name of my favorite beer, back in Toledo. I’d go to the bar there, and because I looked older than my age, they’d serve me up some Mud. But those chocolate chip cookies were hard as rock, Danny told me. He said they were so dense that you couldn’t swallow a bite without chugging a gallon of milk, which we used to have to get ourselves from the cow. But, oh, he said it was torture watching her make them. She used every dish in the house. I had myself a few dishes. Somehow, after all of the rigmarole, you could eat her cookies.”

People on Saturday... struggled to find their seats, so concentrated and intense was this sophisticated gathering.

Of course, you didn’t think you were going to get away from a Bernard Converse-Hater article without mention of those elite fucks who go to these damn complex concerts, about which Holland writes and gets paid, did you? Americans who, like Carter, were sophisticated went to the concert, and seemed to be intrigued by it, or according to Holland, were so exhausted that they couldn’t muster the strength to find their own seats.

Yet in the larger world of classical-music audiences—those who find comfort in Mozart, inspiration in Beethoven and exotic fantasies fulfilled in Ravel or the young Stravinsky—Mr. Carter has virtually no audience at all.

In other words, most classically-minded audiences (who mostly live in Europe, by the way) don’t listen to Carter’s music for comfort, inspiration or to fulfill exotic fantasies. In other, other words, Elliott Cater sucks! I hate new music! I hate New American Music! I especially hate new American music that reminds me of Schoenberg!

Laughable running tally—

Carter IS NOT: oxidized, soulful, singing, a Jesus, smooth, simple, sweet, comforting, inspiring. Nor will he fulfill your exotic fantasies.

Carter IS: like paint, new, sharp, a monster, impulsive, aggressive, highly sophisticated, cold, unfeeling, frightening, complex.

I hope, after all this Carter bashing (By the way, he’s fucking 100 years-old! This just further exemplifies Holland’s intellectual cowardice, I believe), Holland will finally tell us what Americans are like. Please, Mr. Shoe? Pretty please? Pretty please with fulfilled exotic fantasies on top?

Like America as seen by some nations [Holland?], he is famous, admired and not particularly liked.

BINGO! In his own words, “America is famous, admired and not particularly liked.” And so is Carter.

I love how Holland draws a parallel between the dislike of America with Elliott Carter. Mr. Elliot writes music. You may not like it. But he just writes music. And to draw this baggage-laden parallel is childish, and sort of, in a way, racist. It’s as if Holland just started writing, like my grandfather rambling, typed enter, and Presto! His work was done.

But go on Mr. Tulip-Levees, I want to know why Carter is not liked, like Americans are not liked.

Also like many Americans in the postwar era, he was born into comfort, has lived in prosperity and functioned with a confidence bordering on impunity.

He just writes music. Why do I care if he is wealthy? Oh wait. Stop, stop, stop. I get it. Holland is saying that Elliott Cater is a social elite. And his bread and butter is to buy more oil companies and step on the little man. Right?

Most of us...

You know, us working-class, blue-collared folk going to Elliott Carter Concerts in New York.

...want everybody to love us, but Mr. Carter seems comfortable with the admiration of the chosen.

Don’t include me Holland Dyke! Speak for yourself. Apparently, Mr. Carter, who is 100 fucking years-old, only cares about himself and other elitist snobs who have money. This is fucking bat-shit crazy bullshit. He's comparing Carter to Eisner, which is like comparing apples to fulfilled erotic fantasies.

“I remember the Great Depression. I was going on fifty, or was it twenty? We lived in a Hooverville just outside of Stockton. My dad picked almonds and my mother picked tomatoes. I picked artichokes twenty hours a day for three pennies, which could buy a new house in those days, but they fired you before you could collect. The girls in the ‘ville would let you collect. The farmers said you didn’t work the whole day, so they couldn’t pay you. We were always trying to get the money, but the jobs weren’t coming. I remember once taking a job writing about the local symphony concerts. But I hated it. The money was good, but I couldn’t stand the clothes you had to wear. A tie and clean long pants. I remember having a pair of shoes that I got back in Modesto. Those were the good old days. I wrote columns about the concerts and the stupid people going to them. I don’t think anyone ever read my reviews, probably reading the more expensive paper across town. There was a good sandwich shop across town; we got the ham. Then...”


....


.... zzzzzz


“.... the Germans! (snort) Oh where was I? Oh. Then we’d get a soda from the street vendor. He used to go to those concerts. But he wasn’t rich. For some strange reason he just liked them because...”


....


.... zzzzzz


....


.... zzzzzz

Check out this comparison article by Allan Kozinn.

I Dream An Editor

Should print journalists be held to lower standards when they are publishing their reviews in "blog" form? Even if the so-called "blog" is attached to the "website" of a print newspaper? Do the editors pop out of existence with a dramatic whooshing sound? Do "blog" writers not have access to spellchecking programs? So many questions! Where's this all leading?!

Here!

Review: Conspirare’s ‘I Dream A World’

Superlatives defy most concerts by Grammy-nominated choir Conspirare.

Uh, okay. I am not sure what this opening sentence means. I hope it means you're not planning on using any superlatives in your column. That would be superlative. (Also: Grammy-nominated? I think I once had a sandwich that was nominated for a Grammy.)

Also: I think that the intent of the sentence is to say that Conspirare concerts, or descriptions thereof, defy the use of superlatives. Or something? I'm pretty sure superlatives don't defy anything. They're words. They haven't the capacity for defiance. I think.

And ’ Dream A World,’

I thought it was called 'I Dream A World'. I'm probably wrong. Your proofreader or editor surely would have noticed if you had mistyped the name of the concert you are reviewing.

the latest program put together by artistic director Craig Hella Johnson,

[Aside: I totally wish my middle name was "Hella".]

proved no exception Thursday night, the first of four presentations in Austin and San Antonio.

No exception to...defying superlatives? Okay, I guess. That seems like a tortuously elaborate construction. Maybe that's your corrective for not using superlatives?

The only choir from the United States invited to participate in the World Symposium on Choral Music this July in Copenhagen, Conspirare tried out some of the music — all by American composers — they’ll perform this summer.

That sounds cool. I'm a fan of supporting American composers. Again with the twisted sentence construction, though. Clarity should be the goal, or so I was taught. Embedded subordinate clauses are cool, but can be obfuscatory. Sometimes a sentence that is its own paragraph might be better as multiple sentences. How about this:

"Conspirare was the only choir from the United States invited to participate in the World Symposium of Choral music this July in Copenhagen. Thursday they tried out some of the music they'll perform this summer, all by American composers."

I do not have any degrees in writing. This is merely a suggestion.

Johnson’s always insightful creative programming

I'm not sure what this means. Does "insightful" modify the compound noun "creative programming"? Because if "insightful" and "creative" both modify "programming", the traditional thing to do is to separate the modifiers with a comma. "...insightful, creative programming..." Perhaps you meant the first thing, or I assume you or your editor would have picked up on this ambiguity.

really sparkled

The insightful creative programming sparkled! Okay, I guess "sparkled" doesn't necessarily count as a superlative. You get a pass on that, for now.

with ‘I Dream A World’ (the title is taken from a Langston Hughes poem).

Hey! I
thought that was the title. You must have just mistyped it, there, earlier. That happens. Other things that happen are re-reading, proofreading, and editing. Except when they don't.

Appalachian folk songs and traditional spirituals joined modern classics and inventive choral arrangementsof [sic] popular songs that all together formed a thoughtful and sophisticate [sic] kaleidoscope of this nation’s varied musical landscape — the perfect profile to present abroad.

Um. I don't know what a "sophisticate kaleidoscope" is, but I'm now determined to get my sister one for Christmas. Also, the space bar is really, really big for a reason. In fact, I think it's the largest key on the keyboard. Is that right? Hold on, let me check. [checks] Yes. Yes it is.

If Samuel Barber’s ‘Adagio for Strings’ stands as one of the most emotionally effecting pieces of 20th-century classical music,

(Note: The following has nothing to do with this fine journalist's fine writing.--Ed.) Barber's Adagio for Strings is lifted from the slow movement of his String Quartet. He subsequently arranged it for String Orchestra, as well as for chorus in the Agnus Dei version mentioned below. It stands as a schlocky, if effective, piece of over-effusive neo-romanticism. Already barely tolerable, since its inclusion in the movie "Platoon" it has gained widespread acceptance and popularity which has rendered it completely insufferable, at least for me.

the choral version of the haunting work — ‘Agnus Dei — shimmers even more with fragile simplicity and emotion.

Ugh. (See above.)

And Johnson and Conspirare mastered every tender, delicate moment in an achingly affective performance.

Ah. Now. I have to say that "every tender, delicate moment" [good use of the comma, by the way!] and "achingly affective" count as superlatives. Right? The kind of adjectives and/or adverbs defied by Conspirare's concerts, vis-a-vis the first sentence of this review?

Eh, maybe I'm nitpicking. Perhaps they're merely descriptive, and not superlative. Easy there, Sator Arepo. Just because her editor was abducted by cat-faced aliens is no reason to pick on the reviewer.

Eric Whitacre’s ‘Leonardo Dreams of His Flying Machine’ was a magnificent modern eight-minute mini-opera with its mesmerizing multiple harmonies, shots of dramatic inflection and sometimes pulsating tempo.

"Magnificent" is definitely a superlative. In fairness, it is used to describe the work and not the performance...I think.

However, 1) "multiple harmonies" is redundant unless you're talking about the most extreme brand of minimalism; 2) "Shots of dramatic inflection" is a meaningless fragment (a dramatic opera? Really?); and 3) "sometimes pulsating tempo" is similarly meaningless. Tempi are measures of speed of pulsations. Tempi pulsate, by definition. Tempo and rhythm are different. The rhythms could accurately (I assume) be described as "sometimes pulsating".

Johnson’;s

Really?

own arrangements surprise and delight.

Borderline superlative, in context. Certainly effusive. Effusion is not defied by Conspirare. Apparently.

His gracious setting of Eliza Gilkyson’s ‘Requiem’

Really? I have an open mind about the pop/classical ("art") music divide, but...really? And: is "gracious" a superlative?

still impresses after its debut last year on Conspirare’s Grammy-nominated double CD.

Okay. Like I said, I have an open mind. It could be good. But this is totally the second time you've mentioned "Grammy-nominated" in this brief review. To recap: winning a Grammy is a dubious honor, at best. Being nominated for a Grammy is tantamount to being the Libertarian presidential candidate.

Johnson’s touch on Dolly Parton’s ‘Light of Clear Blue Morning’

Really?

was utter mastery.

Sorry, "utter mastery" is totally superlative. Haven't you heard? Conspirare defies superlatives!

He brought an ethereal yet modern finesse

I have no idea what this means. It may or may not be superlative.

along with great harmonic depth and new twists on tempo that only Parton’s a;ready-lovely tune

Sigh. Psssht. Clean-up on aisle semicolon typo. Any available editor, clean-up on aisle typo. Psshst.

more astonishingly beautiful. How perfect.

Superlatively astonishingly beautiful. How superlatively perfect.

This Sucks Dick

I'm not sure what to make of this. Philip Glass, scheduled to perform some of his piano music for the University of Miami, received an injury causing him to cancel the performance (Miami Herald).

“One of my kids jumped into my arms... and he bent my finger back.”

He actually told this to a reporter.


But this is also very disturbing.

You most certainly have entertained my dislike of interchangeable/vague-and-meaningless adjectives. And, to a degree, I acknowledge that it may be overly nitpicky. But why waste words, when it can be said in a clear coherent manner? So far, the only answer I have goes something like this:

(speaking as a critic)

The writer of classical music reviews has an obligation to compete, along with the other writers of other subjects and advertisements, for column space and, thus, readership. And the only way to do so is to mimic those “extreme” cultural norms, i.e., over-inflate the language, to give it some Gestalt, to make it sound bigger, to sound more important, than it really is.

My problem is that this kind of writing further confuses the music critic’s readership, alienating them from the possibility of understanding something about unfamiliar music. I do understand that music is ephemeral—it is an art, if you will, of memory—and that adjectives are often necessary to best describe, in word form, what happened. I also accept minor ambiguities, like:

...relentless momentum...

But even there, I find a problem. Does the author intend to suggest that there is a kind of “driving towards a goal,” or “snowballing growth,” momentum? Or does the author mean, instead of momentum, motion? Granted, either interpretation may be relevant to a particular work. However, we’re talking about Philip Glass, whose musical ideas (motifs, phrases, etc.) often meander (minimalism), but the motion is continuous (e.g., fast and continuous eighth-notes).

It is difficult to screw up an interview, or at least in the transcribing of one. And in many respects, this is a very insightful interview. The only problem I have is when Lawrence A. Johnson, the interviewer, interjects, adding his own “insightful” quips. Often, they are fine, or neutral. But this particular segue way, about Glass’s Violin Concerto, just sucks dick.

But first, I’ll give it to you in Mad Lib form.

In many ways the concerto seems to represent Glass at his most approachable and characteristic, imbuing a traditional form with his brand of (adj.) energy, (adj.) riffs and a (adj.), (adj.) lyricism that is distinctive in its (adj.), (adj.) sensibility.

Just remove the adjectives and this sounds pretty good. I get it. But I can still reword it so it’s even more clear:

“The Violin Concerto represents the quintessential Glass: a traditional form infused with his own distinctive brand of energy, riffs and lyricism.”

Personally, I think that sounds very good. But, obviously, this is not what was written. So we continue.

Now, just for fun, try to match the following adjectives with their appropriate placement within the actual sentence.

Sad
Urgent
Rock-like
Urban
Modern
Wistful

In many ways the concerto seems to represent Glass at his most approachable and characteristic, imbuing a traditional form with his brand of (adj.) energy, (adj.) riffs and a (adj.), (adj.) lyricism that is distinctive in its (adj.), (adj.) sensibility.

If you’re like me, the only one that really seems obvious is “rock-like.” Rock-like riffs. Correct! Even if all that comes to mind is “Iron Man,” which is probably not particularly an indicative Glass-ism. That leaves us with these:

Sad
Urgent
Urban
Modern
Wistful

And this:

In many ways the concerto seems to represent Glass at his most approachable and characteristic, imbuing a traditional form with his brand of (adj.) energy, rock-like riffs and a (adj.), (adj.) lyricism that is distinctive in its (adj.), (adj.) sensibility.

Aside from “rock-like,” I don’t feel confident assigning an adjective to the other blanks. I could make a case for and against every adjective in every space.

This is my problem with over-abundant adjectives. If you merely gloss over the sentence (in it’s original form) I can kind of get a sense of what Glass is about (or what Larry Johnson thinks about Glass), in which case the adjectives did their jobs. However, if I really think about the appropriateness of each one, I get confused. Very confused. Is it really “modern energy?” Or “urban energy?” Or “urgent energy?” I don’t know. Each one sort of makes sense. But, because “urgent energy” is not a thing, nor is it sufficiently differentiated from “traditional form,” I would have guessed that the correct pairing is “urban energy.”

Here’s the actual sentence:

In many ways the concerto seems to represent Glass at his most approachable and characteristic, imbuing a traditional form with his brand of urgent energy, rock-like riffs and a sad, wistful lyricism that is distinctive in its modern, urban sensibility.

Just sad.

That said, and to hedge a little, this was a very interesting interview. It was mostly, well-written. But, this one sentence, this one confusing, misleading, over-inflated excuse of a sentence, chaps my hide. There were so few opportunities to really F this up.

Like I’ve said before, this is not an isolated case of Color Me Badd journalism, it’s rampant, almost to a point where it’s the standard. This is one of the reasons why The Detritus exists. I just happened to catch Lawrence Johnson on a bad day. One on which Glass outs his son for sabotaging a concert.

This Sucks Hard

Nearly a year after the sudden death of U.C. Berkeley composition professor, John Thow, the school is reeling from the passing away of yet another faculty composer. 50-year-old, Jorge Liderman, apparently committed suicide yesterday, as reported by the San Francisco Chronicle.

Jorge has been a fixture in the Bay Area’s new music scene for over a decade, while his international reputation grew at an unyielding pace. Please, check out his stuff; it’s orchidacious.

John Thow, similarly, was a Bay Area regular, joining the school’s faculty in 1981. His work has been commissioned and performed by the San Francisco Symphony Orchestra, among others. He was a terrific flute player. Please, check out his stuff; it’s hibisculicious.

The Detritus Review is saddened by U.C. Berkeley’s recent losses, and offer our heartfelt condolences to the Liderman family, the Thow family, the U.C. Berkeley family, and to those who have been touched by their presence.

2/3/08

Composer of the Day!

Today’s Composer of the Day is Kaija Saariaho.

(b. 1952)

Kaija was born in Finland.

Her music reflects a deep interest in psychoacoustics, particularly the differences between harmony and timbre. It has been said that the music abolishes parametric hierarchies, creating a new kind of organic framework. Others contend that she creatively reorganizes parametric hierarchies. I think the music is just lovely.

Kaija’s works often blend idiomatic instrumental writing (“idiomatic” being another term for virtuosic) and computer generated sounds (click here). Yet, the means are overshadowed by the result. The pieces have a musically logical flow; no sound is wasted.

Her music is also sexy (click here). She revels in the female voice’s femininity. Thus, a lot of her pieces contain a female vocal part.

She has won awards. She is well-known in Europe, but not so much in the States. She has studied with composers, including Brian Ferneyhough and Klaus Huber.

She is also a founding member of Petals, a non-profit organization for the dissemination of commercially underrepresented musical projects.

You should definitely listen to her music.

2/2/08

Fast Eddie's School of Music Criticism

The professor’s name was Fast Eddie. He was peculiar, to say the least. He wore a plaid fedora, in which there was an old betting stub (or so it seemed) stuck hastily in the collar. In his jacket pocket there was a tattered spiral notebook and several unsharpened pencils, lead end up. He walked with unusual speed, very deliberate, but nervous. And this is how he spoke, too.

His lesson, which was alarmingly curt, went something like this:

Eddie: Nice t’meechyas, class. I’ll make this quick. Then ya can get into the game, presto. Just like that, see? Now whatcha gotta do is give em a line. A headline. Somethin colorful. Maybe it has somthin t’do with the players, maybe not. Just go for the gusto. Maybe something like this: (waves hand like reading a headline)

Sober Bartok With a Swirling Finale

They like that. They’ll go nuts for it. But it’s gotta be vague, intriguing. See? You gotta keep em wanting more. Cause that’s how ya make the big moolah. Then ya give em somethin over their heads. It’ll be like, “I’m smart and ya gotta listen to me.” Maybe somethin like this:

Big ideas in music gravitate toward big sounds.

T’ them, the saps, the writin sounds big. Gotta be big. Then ya follow that up with another doozey. A real zinger. See? They’ll be hooked in no time. Guaranteed. They’ll be throwin their money atcha. It’s like call and answer. Like a phone call: “Hey, how’s it goin, Marty?”

“F.U. Where’s my money, Fast Eddie? I gave you two weeks.” See? Zing! Zip! Flashy and a bit ballsy. See? Maybe something like this:

Well used, a single instrument does even better.

See? It don’t have to make sense. They’ll fall over themselves. They’ll be crazy for ya. You got em where ya want em. They gotta read the whole thing now. They cant get enough of ya.

Now all ya have t’do is apply my, “Quick and Easy,” formula. There’s a couple a things ya gotta know first. One, you don’t have to make sense. Ya already got em reading, that’s the main thing. It don’t matter whatcha do after. Just keep writin. And two, whatever ya do write, it’s gotta be colorful. I mean, ya don’t want a cheesesteak without the peppers. Am I right? Bingo, bango. Just add some sugar to the coffee.

The formula is easy. See? You just kinda throw in some names and you “pepper” em up. Make em sound expensive. Like the saps need to want this bull. Make em want to spend some more money.

If ya got “Concerto for Orchestra,” ya do it up like this:

great ode to symphonic luxury.

Zing! I am right?

If it’s loud, make it louder.

...public declamation filled with color and exclamation points.

See? It’s an f’in sonata. Just a fancy way t’say loud. They’ll eat it up. And if ya have to, exaggerate a little. It never hurt anyone, nohow.

If a lovlier, more touching piece of linear writing exists in 20th-century music, I don’t know it.

Ya gotta show some humility, too. Ya don’t wanna insult the poor slobs. If they get their little feelins hurt, it ain’t gonna go good.

And if ya didn’t like the show, hide it a bit. Like thankin someone for givin ya socks on Christmas. Do it up like this:

Brahms was good at destroying music he did not want remembered, but the C minor Scherzo at the start of this impressive evening might have escaped by hiding itself inside a hybrid sonata.

Oh yeahs. And always two adjacent adjectives. The more the better. Am I right? Or am I right? Or sometimes, hows bout an adjective that modifies an adverb? Always a winner. Stick to my formula and you'll be writin good in no time. You can take that t' the bank; better than a two-to-one at the track.

Alright knuckleheads, class over. Ask the bartender for your corrected homework on the way out.

-

This transcription was provided to me by an anonymous source. This source also mentions a few names who attended this class. Those names will be made available at the appropriate time. Here, is one of them.
-

2/1/08

Composer of the Day!

Today's Composer of the Day is Galina Ustvolskaya.

(1919-2006)

(This seems to be the standard picture of her. Why do her hands look penciled in?)

Ustvolskaya was a Russian/Soviet composer with a distinctly individual, experimental style.

During the Soviet years, her music was suppressed as decadent (and, notably, quasi-religious), but she managed to make a living writing pro-Soviet screed pieces. Her main composition teacher was Dmitri Shostakovich. He admired her greatly, and (after the death of his first wife) unsuccessfully asked her to marry him.

She declined. After a time, she broke free of her mentor's influence and developed a unique style of composition including tone clusters, pounding rhythms, and unique instrumental combinations. For example, her piece Composition No. 2 is scored for 8 double basses, piano, and percussion (a wooden box!). Interestingly, all of the pieces in her representative (that is, not Soviet-official) style include piano, percussion, or both.

Her insistence on large, repeated blocks of sound earned her the moniker "The Lady with the Hammer." Which is an awesome nickname. Her music is unique and beautiful.

You can hear the part of the aforementioned Composition No. 2 here. I have no idea what the video is about. It sure is strange though.

She was opinionated. Some great quotes are here. Although she remains relatively obscure, there exist recordings for you to purchase. Or download, whatever.

You should listen to her music.

Classical Music is Boring! And: Nobody Likes It (Except Old People).

Looking for the Classical Music reviews on the Chicago Sun-Times' website is sort of like trying to find fresh endive at the supermarket. You know it must be there, somewhere. But it seems as though they don't want you to find it. (Try it! Lifestyle? No. Entertainment and the Music tab both take you to oceans of club listings and pop reviews. Arts? Oh, visual arts.) One would think that the primary newspaper in a major city with one of four major American orchestras would have a vibrant "art" music scene. Maybe they do. They sure hide it well.

After some searching, I found this little gem. This gentleman, apparently, gets paid (if occasionally) to write about music. Now, I realize that classical music is, perhaps, not his milieu. Also...wait, you know what? No more hedging.

"Catching Some Zs in D Minor"

Midway through Quintet Attacca's performance at the Chicago Cultural Center last Monday afternoon, I spied a fellow audience member stifling a yawn.

Classical music is boring!

She had a right; along with the other fifth graders from Henson Elementary School in attendance, she'd just used up all her energy playing impressive versions of "Jolly Old St. Nicholas" and "The Gift of G-A-B" on the recorder.

Oh, sorry. I spoke too soon. She was just a tuckered-out little kid. Classical music isn't boring. Not for nothing, but I really want to know more about "The Gift of G-A-B". I wonder if it was constructed around linear ascent through a major third?

Dave and I, on the other hand, had no excuse for dozing off during the event, unless you count staying up late to watch Sunday Night Football.

Okay. You're a regular [read: likes football] guy who also enjoys the occasional classical music concert. That's cool. Trying to expand the audience is cool with me! How was the concert? Who's Dave?

"I wouldn't call that 'rambunctious'," noted Dave as he was startled awake by the set-ending applause.

I wouldn't call staying up for Sunday Night Football "rambunctious" either. Who's Dave? Your roommate?

He was referring to flautist Jennifer Clippert's introductory description of Irving Fine's "Partita for Wind Instruments."

Oh. The "that" in the previous sentence referred to something you hadn't mentioned yet. Who's Dave?

"I guess it's all relative," I replied, stretching.

Your casual, narrative style seems designed to put me at ease. I hope.

I had been counting on Dave to keep me interested in the concert, since he was once a dedicated cello player (his prized instrument was stolen last year; he is currently offering a free haircut for anyone who can ensure its safe return).

That is sad. Dave is forced to be a hairdresser for a living since his cello was stolen? Or had he previously given up music in favor of a career in hairdressing? Um, who's Dave?

Also, you expected the concert to be soporific (since classical music is boring) and expected your classical nerd buddy (or something) to keep you interested. Your casual, narrative, parenthetically anecdotal tone is starting to wear thin. However, I'll keep a positive attitude. How was the concert?

But the Quintet's songs proved to be an effective, if pleasurable, sleep aid,

Oh. Classical music is boring.

and my roommate and the 60-year old spectator to his right were soon dreaming woodwind dreams.

Really boring. Soporific, even. Literally! Plus: new information! Dave is totally your roommate. I assume. Although I am not sure, given your predilection to postpone predicates.

Forced to fend for myself, I spent much time looking around Preston Bradley Hall, the home of the Classical Mondays concert series.

Good thing you weren't listening to the music. Otherwise you might be able to tell me how you liked the concert. I know: how about a digression!

The ornate room, featuring the world's largest stained-glass Tiffany Dome, is a clear reminder of the building's previous life as the Chicago Public Library. It's covered with multilingual inscriptions about books as well as the names of masters like Shakespeare, Chaucer and Dante.

That sounds really nice. It sounds like a nice place to be. I wish I had a blog making fun of architecture reviews. How was the concert? Boring? So boring you were reading the names of authors? On the wall?

It's also huge, and much to my surprise, the space was needed for this concert.

This is awesome. It is surprising to Dave's everyman-roommate Ben (a writer) that people come to free classical concerts. Much surprising!

While I'd expected some Loop workers on lunch break and maybe a street-dweller or two looking for a respite from the cold,

Classical music is boring. Nobody likes it. Concerts of this type (especially, I guess, free ones) are mostly attended by street people, who are cold.

I wasn't prepared for the packed house that left me just inches away from the bobbing head of the man in front of me.

I guess not. People? At a concert? Bobbing?!

Evidently, the description of the award-winning Quintet Attacca as "up and coming" isn't just PR spin; the group is clearly popular with the coveted 45- to 75-year-old market.

Hey-O! Derision of the middle-aged and elderly. That was totally necessary! You know who likes classical music? Old people. Take that, old people!

I could only imagine how many homebound fans were listening to the live broadcast on WFMT (98.7 FM).

Take that, homebound fans! You are totally homebound. And you know what else? You like classical music. Which is boring. By the way, Ben, how was the concert?

Classical concerts demand a certain level of propriety, and the well-mannered audience members were model citizens throughout.

The audience, which consisted of a) tuckered-out fifth-graders, b) football-loving everymen Ben and Dave, and c) boring old people, was well-mannered. This is awesome journalism.

Though I'm a rule-follower to a fault, I was tempted to shake things up, if only in a last-ditch effort to stay awake.

It was so fucking boring.

As long as I had to watch horn player Jeremiah Frederick empty out his spit valve at every pause, why couldn't I clap when the urge struck?

Brass instruments accumulate spit as a result of the physical necessities of generating sound through a metal tube using your mouth. This is very, very slightly gross and has nothing to do with your clapping "when the urge struck". I don't really understand. How was the concert? Boring? How's Dave doing about now?

Sadly, Dave wasn't alert enough to share in my civil disobedience,

Ah, bored to sleep. But well-mannered!

and I had to sit on my hands like everyone else until the group members stood up to signal for applause.

That must've been torture. Boring torture.

The performers weren't all business; their colorful and informative introductions to each piece elicited chuckles from the crowd, and revealed their deep understanding of musical history.

The performers sound well-informed. Their "colorful" introductions sound pretty cool. This sounds a lot like the kind of newer, casual style of "classical" concerts that younger ensembles stage nowadays in order to educate and interest a wider audience. I think that's exemplary.

I wonder if they played well, too? How was the selection of pieces? How was the concert?

My personal favorite was the preface to Arturo Marquez' "Danza de Mediodia." Oboist Erica Anderson explained that the title translated to "Noon Dance," and referred not to the time of day, but rather the stage the Mexican composer was at in his career when he wrote it.

What was your favorite piece?

According to Anderson, the song is meant to be played standing, but due to aesthetic concerns and the weight of Collin Anderson's bassoon, the group members would be "dancing from [their] seats."

I'm not really sure what this means, or where it's going. I'm sure you are driving at something here. Do you approve? Disapprove? What was the effect? How was the piece? How was the concert? How is Dave?

Amidst all the post-noon swoons and kids eager to get back on the school bus, I'm sure there were a few toes politely tapping in the audience as well.

That's it? That's the end? For fuck's sake man! How! was! the! concert!? Did Dave ever wake up?

The Silliest Opening Sentence Ever

Richard Harrington, a staff writer for the Washington Post, was asked to write a preview for the upcoming Laptop Orchestra concert, performing at the Kennedy Center’s Theatre Lab. He opens with something that may be loosely categorized as “free-association.” I find it really, really silly. Especially considering that the entire article is well-written, for the most part, except for this little part:

A Laptop Orchestra performance looks like a bunch of students working in a college library, intently focused on their screens as they contemplate assorted mouse movement.

Like I said, aside from the opening sentence, this is probably the worst bit of writing. This isn’t all that bad, either. It just implies that the orchestra is, perhaps, a little nerdy, or, maybe, even intellectual. No biggie.

But the opening sentence... whew! It’s a gasser. It’s so stupid, it’s stupid-er than this dorky witticism:

It’s a brave new platform...

Ha, ha, ha, ha, ha! Now that’s wordplay! Get it? Platform? Laptops? A Brave New World? Aldous Huxley? A Tokyo Laptop Orchestra?

Okay, really. There’s nothing else to make fun of. It’s a good article. Except the opening sentence. Which is totally lame. And he’s entirely correct.

No one will ever confuse Tokyo’s Laptop Orchestra with the Duke Ellington or Count Basie orchestras.

No. I don’t believe anyone will.

Thank you.
-

Holland's Tunnel of Misinformation

Saint Bernard just can’t write a piece without mentioning Schoenberg. It’s old hat. We know that, already. And that is why I’m only going to spend a few seconds trying to parse this subtle assault on our intelligence.

In an article ostensibly about Monteverdi’s Vespers, Mr. Holland praises the works’ canon-worthiness.

How startling, for example, [Monteverdi's] galloping brass writing must have sounded to contemporary ears: an early 17th-century audience innocent of Mozart’s diminished seventh chords, Wagner’s wandering key changes or Schoenberg’s serialist combinations.

Holland and his 1974 Grove Dictionary of Music must be missing a couple of volumes. Mozart didn’t invent the diminished-seventh chord, nor was Wagner the first to meander.

I was going to list earlier composers who also used the diminished-seventh chord, but I didn’t. Suffice it to say, there were quite a few, maybe all of them. In addition, I was going to list all of the composers who had previously changed keys in a wandering way, but I didn’t. Again, there were too many. I believe that nobody could convince me that either composer was the chief proponent of the attributed startling doings. Except Schoenberg's attributed doings; that is correct (for the most part). One for three; Holland's batting an astounding .333. Good work so far (for baseball).

And since Holland’s pocket music dictionary must be waterlogged from trudging to concerts in hurricane-force weather, he defines, from memory, “hocket” as:

...the stuttering repetitions of single notes in the vocal parts...

But really, it is defined here. I’m not going to type it, just read the link. Mr. Holland is plainly wrong. He's now one for four--a below league batting average of .250. That's not so good.

Just saying, the NY Times is where a good portion of the concert-going public gets its information about “classical” music, and Mr. Holland writes for the Times, for which you have to pay real money, which goes to Mr. Holland.
-

Composer of the Day!

Today’s Composer of the Day is Vinko Globokar.

(b. 1934)

This delightful composer is a traveler. He was born in France. He then moved to Yugoslavia. He also moved to Germany, where he worked with, none other than...





Karlheinz Stockglaubenmunchendiefledermaushausen.

He’s held conducting posts pretty much everywhere else.

Vinko is also a very good trombone player.

His music, while extremely original, has been compared to that of Helmut Lachenmann. He, too, uses extended techniques! You can catch some of it here.

He also held a post at IRCAM; but he is not dead.

You should listen to his music.