Here’s a nice enough idea:
The Redlands Symphony Orchestra will celebrate America's contribution to music…
Hmm. What is America’s contribution to music? For now, just keep that in mind. It’ll be important later on.
…in their season's final concert Saturday night, offering a program of American and Americana works. The program features Morton Gould's "American Salute," the Overture to "On the Town" by Leonard Bernstein, Aaron Copland's "Appalachian Spring" and Symphony No. 2 "Romantic" by Howard Hanson.
I am especially happy to see they’re programming Gould and Hanson, two very undeservedly neglected composers. I mean, there are names other than Gershwin, Bernstein, Copland, and Barber, don’t you know? Still, I can’t shake the feeling that orchestras are a small part of a mega-conglomerate that makes and sells American flags and, sometimes, Russian flags.
Anyway, let’s hear more about this promising concert.
"It's like splitting hairs lengthwise…
Plot twist: In case you were thinking I was going to take to task the author of this review, think again. The conductor, asked for some quips to fill some space in this Press-Enterprise puff piece, potentially errs in some way, or…uh, lengthwise.
"It's like splitting hairs lengthwise to distinguish between American and Americana," said conductor Jon Robertson as he discussed the program's composers […]
Well then. Distinguish away!
"Americana music reflects the American sound, usually with some elements of folk music or rhythmic music like jazz -- jazz being the American contribution to music."
Ah ha! So that’s the American contribution to music—jazz. Good to know.
To Robertson, the Hanson symphony is a good example of strictly American music…
So it’s nothing but folk music and jazz?
…that is, music composed by an American in a European style and structure.
Oh. So a touch of folk music or jazz is Americana (suspiciously nationalistic, if you ask me) and music written by an American is American. I’ll buy these distinctions. You?
To me, however, this is the first weird juncture. According to Mr. Robertson, America’s contribution to music was jazz and symphonic composers used jazz in their music. Fine. But let me ask this: why not go see jazz instead? Why should I pay to see watered-down American jazz or folk in a European-instituted venue? Besides, as the conductor of a symphony, aren’t you supposed to promote your organization?
Personally, I’m hardcore; gimme the good stuff.
"Copland -- now, that is clearly Americana, with the beautiful Shaker tune of 'Simple Gifts,' " said Robertson. "And Bernstein, too, is Americana with all the jazzy elements. The Gould piece is another example as it takes the tune of 'Johnny Comes Marching Home Again' and orchestrates it into a big piece."
There is some dispute whether or not “Johnny” is in fact American. So…
There.
Robertson asserts that you can't hear that sound in other countries' music. "If you do, they copied it from us."
We most certainly hear jazz in other countries’ music. And by definition it’s still Americana.
But what I find odd about this whole “who copied who?” business are the arbitrary lines one must draw when making this assertion. Does borrowing a V-I cadence constitute copying from European music? What about all the American composers who have appropriated “Sheep May Safely Graze?” Are they copycats? On the flip side, I wonder if any Austrian critics boast that American composers still write for the string quartet.
Robertson has a theory about why Americana music is so appealing to listeners.
Yikes! Non sequitor. [abruptly shifts gears] Still, this has to be entertaining, given the above theorizing.
"Back in the time when avant garde music…
Here we go again.
"Back in the time when avant garde music was all that was being composed for orchestras, the listeners rejected it in droves.
Correction: Back in the fictitious time when avant garde music was all that was being composed for orchestras…
“At the same time [sic?], people were going to the movies and hearing beautifully accessible music written by highly-trained European composers who the film houses brought to America.
FYI Mr. Robertson: “beautifully accessible music” means that the accessibility was beautiful. I doubt that’s what you meant.
“These composers weren't just hacks. Without realizing it, film-goers were hearing really good music, and responding to it."
So it’s appealing because people liked it? Well that sounds like a wristwatch-challenged argument.
According to Robertson, Americana music fits naturally with the ear.
That’s the theory? It fits naturally with the ear? What the fuck does that mean?
"When you hear Copland or Bernstein, you just naturally enjoy it. It's really in the ear," he said.
Oh that clarifies everything. [snicker]
Listen. The point I’m try to articulate is that Mr. Robertson is promoting something that I think is somewhat detrimental to the health of American music. And I don’t think it’s completely unfair to draw a metaphor from the fast food industry.
Here’s what I mean: Big Macs are bad for you—we all know that. But they’re engineered in such a way that you can’t resist them. They’ve got all the goodies that we find naturally appealing: tons of fat and tons of sugar.
Instead, maybe that’s the defining characteristic of Americana.
-
5/31/09
You're Lovin' It!
Posted by Empiricus at 2:43 PM 2 comments
Labels: American Music, Americana, Bic Mac, Enjoyment, Fast Food, Howard Hanson, Jon Robertson, Morton Gould, Press Enterprise, Sherli Leonard
5/6/08
Hot Stuff from 1944, Ewww!
I must say, at the onset, that ClassicsToday is a good resource for those looking to find assessments of new recordings that often get overlooked by newspapers. And most of the reviews do, in fact, take into account the review philosophy set down by Executive Editor David Hurwitz. Only, he doesn’t write those ones. Historically, he forgoes the review philosophy completely, opting to address the quality of the music, which tends to expose his blatant dislike, nay disdain, of new music (by “new,” I mean music written after 1900).
So, from now on, I’m going to treat David Hurwitz as if the review philosophy didn’t exist. I won’t go on and on about how he didn’t address the “sound quality” or the “performance.” Instead, I’ll focus on what he says about the music. I think it would be easier on both of us.
That said...
Steven Stucky's Son et Lumière is one of those modern, anonymous-sounding "texture" pieces,
...this is fucked up beyond all recognition. He admits that he lumps—maybe categorizes if I were nice—music into modern/not modern, anonymous/authored and “texture”/ “_____” subsections worth easily dismissing. How condescending is that “those!” It’s like, “We need to build a gigantic wall to keep those Mexicans out!” “Texture” in quotations? Give me a break, David.
I would like to propose a new word to describe the irrational hatred of unfamiliar music: xenophonephobia.
Take that Bernard Hollands of the world!
...but it's no less rewarding for that as Stucky writes for the orchestra with great flair and confidence and the piece delivers exactly what the title promises: interesting sounds featuring an enjoyable interplay of light and shade.
Well, the title...only sort of. Wiki magic! But,
David actually...gulp...liked the piece? That might be a bit strong. I think that he was pleasantly indifferent to it.
*Have you ever gone to new music concert, mingled with the composers afterward and said something like, “Your piece was...um...interesting...and um...well-written,” but you didn’t really care for it and you were just being nice? No. Screw you! That’s happened to me.
Either way, Hurwitz sort of apologizes for his outright dismissal of one of “those” pieces, because it was interesting. Could he be turning a modernist corner?
Gabriel Ian Gould (no relation to Morton) is a young (b. 1974) composer whose Watercolors for English horn and orchestra is a sort of Swan of Tuonela for the New Millennium. If my preferences remain firmly with the old swan, this is still an attractive 12 minutes of pastels, the perfect contrast to Stucky's "in-your-face" opening.
“Attractive?” Wow. Maybe Hurwitz finally jumped on the 20th-century bandwagon.
But now comes the really hot stuff.
What’s that? Hot stuff? (puts on swimming goggles)
John Harbison's Cello Concerto (1993) strikes me as one of his most successful instrumental works, largely on account of very colorful orchestration that features an "East meets West" assortment of gongs and tuned percussion. The result avoids the timbral dullness that afflicts many of Harbison's other works, as does the inventive solo part that cellist David Finckel (of Emerson String Quartet fame) plays with admirable relish. You can enjoy this repetition-friendly work at first hearing and return to it with increasing pleasure as your familiarity with its captivating sound world deepens.
Amazing what can happen when you don’t outright dismiss things.
The main event, Morton Gould's Symphony No. 2 "On Marching Tunes", will come as a shock to those who think that the subtitle, the composer's reputation as a musical populist, and the date of composition (1944) mean that we're going to be treated to some sort of nationalistic pot-boiler. Indeed, the opening Variations and zesty third-movement Quickstep offer plenty of evidence to support that notion. They are brilliant and tremendous fun. But the second movement, Bivouac, really is a tenderly nostalgic berceuse, and the long, slow finale, Memorial, carries the music into regions inhabited by the finale of Shostakovich's Eighth Symphony, which it strongly resembles in its grief-stricken emotional ambiance and quietly ambivalent "major-key" ending.
The only problem I have with this is that Hurwitz likes the oldest piece best; it’s his most favoritest. Though, I’m not surprised with his preference, being a xenophonephobiac and all.
Let’s play a quick game. Queue the soundtrack. And. Go!
Son et Lumière (1988)
Cello Concerto (1993)
Watercolors (1998)
Symphony 2 (1944)
That was fun, wasn’t it?
[...] I have no doubt that it deserves to be ranked among the finest of 20th century symphonies.
Because it resembles Shostakovich’s Eighth Symphony’s “grief-stricken emotional ambience?” Air-tight logic that I will not attempt to crack. Not in a million-billion years.
Even if you don't respond positively to the other pieces on the disc (and they all are a touch more "modern" than Albany's musical average), you will find owning Gould's masterpiece well worth the outlay.
That sucks. He fucked up an otherwise good, for David Hurwitz, review (don't forget that we omitted the review philosophy) with one little, stinking “modern” in quotation marks. I mean, he was doing well for a while, then, thhbbbt! He shoved new music to the side, once again.
It’s sad. Even if we don’t hold Hurwitz up to the same review standards, which he penned, as we do others at ClassicsToday, we’re still left with shoddy writing and a classic case of xenophonephobia.
-
Posted by Empiricus at 11:34 AM 3 comments
Labels: classicstoday.com, David Hurwitz, Gabriel Ian Gould, John Harbison, Morton Gould, Shostakovich, Steven Stucky, xenophonephobia