9/4/09

"Galaxy nearly destroyed," says local scientist...

"...The encounter could create a time paradox, the results of which could cause a chain reaction that would unravel the very fabric of the space time continuum, and destroy the entire universe! Granted, that's a worse case scenario. The destruction might in fact be very localized, limited to merely our own galaxy."
Doc Brown, Hill Valley, 2015


So, John Daly-Peoples, of the National Business Review, writes a preview of the performance of Mahler's Sixth Symphony by the Auckland Philharmonia.


figure 1: A different John Daly playing a little shirtless golf. Not fun to look at.

MAHLER'S TRAGIC TALE

This week the Auckland Philharmonia will be playing one of the first and probably the greatest autobiographical symphony of the twentieth century with Gustav Mahler’s sixth symphony.

Autobiographical symphony? Okay, I guess. Premiered in 1906, and sometimes know by the editorial title "Tragic Symphony", many historians, and even Mahler's wife have made overtures of the autobiographical meanings in the work.

However, Mahler was seemingly at a happy point in his life, having recently married Alma Schindler and enjoyed the birth of a baby daughter during the composition of the piece...but hey, I didn't know the guy, perhaps it was inner torment.


But I digress...

Beethoven’s great symphonies portray mankind in a heroic manner. He attempted to show man in pursuit of higher aims but they were figures of almost mythic proportions.

I guess it is true that you can't write about Mahler without mentioning Beethoven...

Mahler on the other hand puts himself at the centre of the music with the music expressing his own fears, emotions and aspirations.

Like the contemporary thinkers such as Sigmund Freud he was endeavoring to find the universal truths from within the individual.


Composed in the early years of the twentieth century the sixth symphony...

wait for it...

Composed in the early years of the twentieth century the sixth symphony presages the tumultuous world evenmts [sic] to come.

The symphony does what now? Presages? So it's not just autobiographical, it's a fortune teller?


figure B: Who knew?

Is Mahler not aware that having knowledge of the future could possibly screw up the space-time Continuum and endanger his own existence?



figure trois: "Marvin, you gotta play. See that's where they kiss for the first time on the dance floor. And if there's no music, they can't dance. If they can't dance, they can't kiss. If they can't kiss they can't fall in love, and I'm history. "

And oh, "evenmts"
?

It also prefigures the calamities which would afflict the composer; the death of his daughter, his loss of prestige in being dumped from the Vienna Sate Opera and his being diagnosed with a terminal heart condition.

Damn. I wonder how his fate would have been different if he had just added more cowbell?

Are we not at least a little surprised that Mahler had supernatural powers? Is this common knowledge -- Mahler gazed into the future and wrote a symphony about what he saw?

Guess so. Although, to be fair, in the original program notes Mahler added this little anecdote that may illuminate his omens of doom in the work:

"Last night, Darth Vader came down from planet Vulcan and told me that if I didn't take Lorraine out that he'd melt my brain."


figure 4: Darth Vader presages tumultuous world events to Mahler.


----------------------

From now on, when writing and thinking intellectually about music, can we agree to seek out rational explanations for the underlying story behind a piece of music rather than to attribute mystical powers? Thanks.


4 comments:

Danny Liss said...

For better or worse, this sort of thing is always going to be part of the narrative with Mahler. While the article certainly could have been better, the whole Kindertotenlieder and Symph- er, Das Lied von der Erde situations do color the way people look at his life.

I mean, I have a degree in music theory and don't buy the whole "c-minor chords are intrinsically sad" BS (which I recognize is actually cultural conditioning), so I'm about as by-the-books as they get, and yet I don't listen to Mahler in any sort of moving vehicle. His life brings out the melodramatic in people, and the music doesn't really do anything to stop it.

Sator Arepo said...

Danny's probably right; well, at least I agree with what he's saying. Still, articles such as this, instead of being taken at face value, open up discussions about the subject, which I think is Gustav's intent.

Plus that John Daly pic is pretty awesome.

Danny Liss said...

The other thing that I forgot to mention last night is that in The Unanswered Question, Leonard Bernstein comes really close to suggesting that the last movement of Mahler's 9th is about, among other things, the Kennedy Assassination. His catalogue hits pretty much every cataclysmic event in the Western World from 1909-1973.

We can't know what the narrative might have been for Mahler had he lived another 25-35 years and produced another 10-20 symphonies. That's probably the only way the world would be able to take his symphonies of middle age at face value.

Sator Arepo said...

Ah, almost forgot.

In re: "evenmts":

A) Colorful Aussie colloquialism (presumably shorthand for "events which contain Mathilda" [who, presumably, waltzes])

B) Merely another case of lack of quality and/or any editing; which is funny both because it's a typo and we all do it, *and* because it's a typo, and some people are paid to catch those things when other people write words for money.

Bonus pointless Simpsons reference:

Money, if you'll recall, can be exchanged for goods and services.